Cookie Consent by FreePrivacyPolicy.com
The True Cost of Hiring In-House vs Outsourcing Your Books
1

The Direct Cost Comparison

In-House Bookkeeper (South Africa average)

Cost Item Monthly Estimate
Salary (experienced bookkeeper) R20,000 – R30,000
PAYE, UIF, SDL Contributions ± R2,000 – R3,000
Leave Pay, Sick Leave, Bonuses Variable but material
Software Licences & Tools R500 – R1,000
Equipment & Office Space R500 – R1,000
Ongoing Training Costs Variable
Total Monthly Cost ± R25,000 – R35,000

Outsourced Bookkeeping (Bletchleys model)

Cost Item Monthly Estimate
Full-service bookkeeping, compliance & reporting ± R6,000 – R12,000 (depending on business complexity)
SARS submissions included
VAT, PAYE, Payroll handled
SARS correspondence managed
Full reporting & financial advisory
Equipment, software, training Already included
Total Monthly Cost ± R6,000 – R12,000

📌 In simple terms:
Outsourcing typically costs 50% to 70% less than hiring full-time, with a wider skillset included.

2

The Hidden Costs of In-House Bookkeeping

When you hire in-house, the salary is only the start. You also take on:

  • Recruitment and hiring costs
  • HR and disciplinary risks
  • Staff turnover disruptions
  • Leave management (sick, annual, maternity)
  • Training, supervision, and upskilling
  • Increased payroll compliance
  • Dependence on one person’s knowledge

If your in-house bookkeeper resigns unexpectedly, you may face:

  • Backlogs in SARS submissions
  • Unreconciled financials
  • Missed VAT or PAYE deadlines
  • SARS penalties and verifications

📌 Tip: Outsourcing eliminates single-person dependency and ensures full continuity, even during staff changes.

3

The Expertise Comparison

In-House

  • Limited to one person’s experience and skillset
  • Risk of outdated knowledge as SARS regulations change
  • May struggle with complex issues (SARS verifications, audit prep, advisory needs)

Outsourced (Bletchleys)

  • A full team of specialists: bookkeepers, payroll professionals, tax practitioners, SARS compliance experts
  • Constantly updated on legislation and best practices
  • Proactive financial advice included
  • Full-service coverage for bookkeeping, tax, payroll, CIPC, and compliance

📌 Tip: Outsourcing gives you access to multiple professionals for less than the cost of one full-time hire.

4

The Time & Focus Factor

With in-house staff:

  • Directors still need to supervise, review reports, approve submissions, and step in during errors or crises.

With outsourcing:

  • Financial management is fully handled.
  • Reports are presented clean, simple, and ready for decision-making.
  • SARS queries, verifications, and penalties are managed without director involvement.

📌 Tip: Outsourcing gives directors time back to focus on sales, clients, and business growth — not admin.

5

The Risk Management Benefit

In-house models create higher exposure to:

  • SARS errors and penalties
  • Missed submission deadlines
  • Incorrect payroll calculations
  • SARS verifications or audits not being handled correctly
  • HR management burdens

Outsourcing with Bletchleys offers built-in protection:

SARS submissions handled accurately and on time
Full compliance monitoring
SARS correspondence and verifications managed directly
Up-to-date financial reporting
Professional indemnity protection

Still debating between hiring and outsourcing?
Let Bletchleys handle your financial function professionally — and free up your business to grow.

Contact us today for a free consultation.

Leave a Reply